Tuesday, February 24, 2009
This Can’t Be Good for Your Reputation
But stories like this aren’t going to help rehabilitate that image. Calabria, a province in Italy’s poorer southern region, is looking to use EU development funds to help promote its soccer team citing, “it can help raise the profile of their area, both within Italy and overseas.” According to one website promoting Italian tourism, Calabria is currently "little-respected by other Italians and little-known to tourists." They expect it’ll cost €1.8 million over three years. I’ve heard of soccer doing a lot of things, but developing a nation isn’t one of them.
Oh and by the way, Calarbia just happens to be home to “the N'Drangheta, one of Italy's most powerful and violent mafia organizations.” Coincidence?
Sunday, August 31, 2008
History Repeating Itself?
This is a major blow for Strasbourg. It’s already not loved by EU critics with many using it as the best example of EU excess. Technically, Strasbourg is the official seat of the European Parliament. EU law mandates that 12 plenary sessions be held in Strasbourg every year. The Espace Leopold complex in Brussels is smaller and is used for only preparatory meetings and non-plenary sessions. This has been a bone of contention for a while. Never mind that Brussels is the hub of most EU business but the cost of moving 790 MEPs and staff back and forth is expensive. The BBC puts the cost at £160 million (the Canadian dollar is twice the worth of one pound).
It’s gotten so bad that when at a conference I was at, a (French) reporter remarked that he believed that the citizen’s initiative—a part of the Lisbon Treaty that would allow EU citizens to propose legislation—was created in order to start a grassroots campaign to abolish Strasbourg as the Parliament’s official headquarters.
Advocates of the Parliament's Strasbourg headquarters—and not just the French who insist on hosting a major EU institution—say that it's important European history keeping the Parliament there. As I mentioned before, Strasbourg has huge symbolism in Europe. It’s located in the Alsace-Lorraine region of France, an area that has been a major bone of contention between France and Germany since the nineteenth century. Having the Parliament there is supposed to be a symbol of Europe overcoming war and strife to form a union. But what does it say about this union when Strasbourg is again at the center of another European cross-country dispute?
Monday, August 11, 2008
Mini Europe, Big Fun
But even before seeing the models, it was painfully obvious what the real purpose of Mini Europe was: propaganda. It’s another effort by the European Union to make Europeans identify with the EU (and to make the kiddies think Europe is great fun; the average age of other Mini-Europe-goers was under 12). This propaganda purpose is demonstrated early on—the first model is Berlaymont (the Commission headquarters in Brussels) and the second is the home of Jean Monnet, another founding father of the EU. Also, the booklet accompanying the tour begins with a message from the Commission President and the head of the European Parliament and the first pages tell of the European values, which include, interestingly enough “democracy, the spirit of adventure, the spirit of enterprise, technology, cultural influence, the Christian heritage (emphasis is my own), social thinking and the “new” value of “secularism and multiculturalism.” I could write a post on this statement alone, but I will refrain for now.
Getting back to the models. They were all done really well and the attention to detail was astonishing: Germany’s Brandenburg Gate display had a portion of the Berlin Wall collapse every 30 seconds; little Eurostar trains passed through the Channel Tunnel; and a special sidewalk shook every time the volcano Vesuvius erupted. But it was sad to see that while older EU states like Italy and Spain or even the Scandinavian countries had five or six models, the ten new Eastern European states usually got one model each. Says a lot about their place in the Union.
The displays on a whole were pretty great. What can I say? I like miniatures. You can go to your music festivals, your museums or foreign lands, but give me a solidly made replica of historical and cultural landmarks and I’m sold. There’s nothing wrong with a model of the Eiffel Tower that is 0.1 per cent of its original size. It just means you can see it clearly and it’ll fit in the frame of my camera easier. In fact, there’s something oddly comforting about a model of the Big Ben that you could step on.
All in all, it was a great. However, I must lodge a complaint. It’s about the Portugal exhibit. Many countries had more than one model and Portugal had five. A few from Lisbon, Porto and the Algarve. For those of you who don’t know (and I’m sure it’s a small minority), I’m from the Algarve area in Portugal. I’ve vacationed there pretty consistently since I was 12. I know what it looks like. And it looks nothing like this.
Friday, June 13, 2008
The power of positive thinking?
When we toured the Parliament last week, I was struck by this structure.
Called Confluences, it is a 36 meter high sculpture in stainless steel. Its parts hang from the ceiling but are not held together at any other point. Touch one part and the whole thing moves. Crafted by Belgian artist Olivier Strebelle, its name has various meanings:
–noun
| 1. | a flowing together of two or more streams, rivers, or the like: the confluence of the Missouri and Mississippi rivers. |
| 2. | their place of junction: St. Louis is at the confluence of the Missouri and Mississippi rivers. |
| 3. | a body of water formed by the flowing together of two or more streams, rivers, or the like. |
| 4. | a coming together of people or things; concourse. |
| 5. | a crowd or throng; assemblage. |
On the tour, our speaker explained the symbolism of this statue was intentionally left ambiguous. Does the sculpture represent the joining of the 27 Member States to form the EU? Or does it represent Strasbourg, the other seat of the European Parliament and, as I mentioned earlier, the historical bone of contention between EU pioneers France and Germany? Is it a symbol that the EU faces; where touching one element/policy area/nation state/issue affects the whole? Does it represent governments at all? Does it represent Europeans coming together to celebrate their common history and geography as Europeans?
Throughout this whole trip, when certain officials have spoken of the EU they have called it the “EU project.” This process of integrating almost 400 million people, 27 nation states, 23 languages (so far) and 15 economies into one voice is an ongoing, evolutionary one. I find this concept and the acceptance of its premise by many within and without the EU, fascinating.
The EU’s motto is “United in diversity.” It sounds pretty and is a noble goal but how feasible is it? When we were at the German Bundesbunk school, one pupil mentioned the older generation’s apprehension to adopt the Euro. But she said the younger generations are more willing because they don’t have that sense of history invested in the German Mark, the Italian Lira or the French Franc. She said as the EU continues to bring prosperity to Europe, attitudes will change. Now, this seems to have hit the nail on the head.
In the absence of a common history, language, culture or any element that traditionally unites a people, shared affluence can be used to create a nation. This isn’t new for Canadians. That’s exactly what John A. MacDonald did to British North America in 1867. The hope is that in time this common culture will be fostered. Has this happened in Canada? If you ask me, no, it has not.
But can it happen in Europe? With the failure of the Constitutional Treaty—whose content is strikingly similar to the Lisbon Treaty save a few nationalist trappings like a common EU flag and national anthem— in 2006 and the failure of this first hurdle for the Lisbon Treaty, it doesn’t look good. It seems like nationalism—that sense that I am a member of this state and that means I’ll do whatever it takes to see it safe and posper –like we see in the United States and Russia, is proving to be the most enduring form of unity.
But it’s an interesting experiment. I, for one, will keep my eye on developments.
Wednesday, June 4, 2008
Yes, Mr. President
The obvious highlight of the day came in the morning when we met the President of the European Parliament, Hans-Gert Pottering.
For those of us not familiar with the inner workings of European Parliaments (and less face it, Europeans are not even experts as one of our speakers, a communications representative, had to defer to his assistant many times), the President is similar to the Speaker of the House in Canada. He has to make sure order is kept and presides over the session (with its 785 MEPs). His signature is needed on all legislation. It is also the President that represents the Parliament externally and so Pottering gets to travel abroad on the EU’s dime.
And so when he arrived in the small room where we had sat for 20 minutes awaiting his arrival, it was like meeting a President of a country, not a Parliament. People who had left the room two minutes earlier to go to the bathroom were quickly ushered back in and the room instantly filled with a dozen more bodies as his entourage flowed in. We stood respectfully when he walked in and clapped after we were introduced. He talked about who he was and the like--and was pretty funny too which was a surprise--but I can’t remember any of it now. What I can remember was the Q&A afterward where I asked him a question. My questions was, “What do you attribute the declining voter turnout in European Union elections to? Especially considering turnout has declined as the Parliament has gotten more power?” The answer: the media. He said voter apathy is a result of the media reporting only bad things about the EU. He then gave an example about how in light of the European Central Banks tenth anniversary a pole found two-thirds of Germans thought the Euro was a good idea. But the paper used as its headline “1/3 of Germans unhappy with Euro.” He ended by saying, “If the media reported better things about the EU, perhaps people would like it more. See what you can do about that.” What’s funny is he didn’t even know I was a journalism student.
The rest of the day paled in comparison. We got to talk to some MEPs (a Irishman, a Brit and a Hungarian). All were great—but especially the Hungarian’s take on Enlargement was irreverent.
Then we saw a plenary session of the Parliament where I was literally 5 minutes away from hearing Javier Solana (aka the EU's foreign ambassador essentially aka an international relations student's idea of heaven) give a progress report to Parliament.
Monday, May 26, 2008
Who Says Monetary Policy Isn't Riveting?
Today we spent some time at the European Central Bank and let me tell you what a swanky place that is. The security checks we went through were more extensive than our time at the Commission and Court combined. They gave us visitors badges, took us through a metal detector and escorted us through two elevators. All this despite the fact that the ECB doesn’t even have money reserves in the building we were in. It was pretty exciting.
We started the morning in the room that the ECB Governing Council sits at to decide on interest rate cuts, which was quite exciting.
All in all the presentations were solid and very informative. True to their reputation, they were efficient and reserved. We were treated very nicely. On our arrival there was a plethora of swag awaiting us: a hardcover book on monetary policy, two brochures on the Eurosystem, a pen and Euro post-its; very impressive indeed. The bank didn’t skimp on food either. After every break there was tea and coffee and scrumptious snacks awaiting us and a beautiful lunch was served in the lounge we were kept in.
The only thing that took away from the day was the fact that I didn’t get to keep the our visitors badge.
Monday, May 19, 2008
Photographic Evidence
Saturday, May 17, 2008
The Mecca of Bureaucracy
After an hour of milling about in the lobby, we were finally ushered past the metal detectors, our visitor's pass in hand and into the lobby, up the elevators (one of 42, by the way) and into the Jean Monnet theatre.
This is the actual meeting room where Member States meet and hammer out the business of Union. We managed to keep our cool for most of the morning, listening attentively and using the EU-star-emblazoned notepads and pencils provided on the desks. But after lunch, things got a little crazy....
But soon enough, it was back to seriousness and back to work.
The Commission also has a beautiful cafeteria. A 900-seat restaurant, it's a mix of cuisines and languages where steak is served beside French fries and broiled fish is offered next to pizza. Anything you could ever want is there. I had (what I think was) steak, French fries, salad (macaroni and mixed greens priced by weight), a bottle of water and a crepe (which was the best I've ever tasted). All for 7 euros! Thank you for subsidized European food! We're back there on Monday and I can't wait.